Truman & Co.
Address
1205 Truman Ave
Key West, FL 33040
21 years ago, five like-minded agents founded Truman & Co., a boutique real estate firm serving Key West and the Lower Keys. Today two of the esteemed founders Terri Spottswood and Lynn Kaufelt carry on the tradition of the firm built on a foundation of expertise, integrity, and a deep commitment to the unique island communities we serve.
As a top-producing real estate firm in the region, we specialize in residential, commercial, and investment properties, offering unparalleled service to buyers, sellers, and investors. Our expertise extends beyond sales—our rental division, Best of Key West Rentals, provides comprehensive vacation and long-term rental management, ensuring exceptional experiences for both property owners and guests.
With a team of highly respected Real Estate Agents and dedicated real estate professionals, Truman & Co. is known for its market knowledge, personalized approach, and track record of success. Whether you’re looking to buy, sell, invest, or rent, we are committed to delivering an elevated real estate experience tailored to your needs.
Discover the Finest Homes in Key West & the Lower Keys.
For Sale
$7,500,000
3750 Sunrise Lane, Key West, FL 33040
For Sale
$6,999,000
223 Eanes Lane, Key West, FL 33040
For Sale
$5,500,000
906 Johnson Street, Key West, FL 33040
For Sale
$4,450,000
1113 Stump Lane, Key West, FL 33040
Active Under Contract
$4,195,000
1311 Grinnell Street, Key West, FL 33040
For Sale
$3,599,000
1501 Georgia Street, Key West, FL 33040
For Sale
$2,599,000
812 Carsten Lane, Key West, FL 33040
For Sale
$2,445,000
800 Fleming Street Unit C1, Key West, FL 33040
$2,299,999
17210 Angelfish Lane, Sugarloaf Key, FL 33042
Active Under Contract
$2,299,999
17210 Angelfish Lane, Sugarloaf Key, FL 33042
For Sale
$2,249,000
1109 Stump Lane, Key West, FL 33040
For Sale
$2,150,000
810 Carey Lane, Key West, FL 33040
Active Under Contract
$2,089,000
1706 Seminary Street, Key West, FL 33040
For Sale
$1,949,000
3841 N Roosevelt Boulevard 315, Key West, FL 33040
For Sale
$1,949,000
3841 N Roosevelt Boulevard 332, Key West, FL 33040
Active Under Contract
$1,899,000
1220 Georgia Street, Key West, FL 33040
For Sale
$1,899,000
1229 5Th Street, Key West, FL 33040
For Sale
$1,899,000
1513 Pine Street, Key West, FL 33040
For Sale
$1,849,000
1800 Atlantic Boulevard 315B, Key West, FL 33040
Active Under Contract
$1,825,000
1115 South Street, Key West, FL 33040
For Sale
$1,799,000
2101 Harris Avenue, Key West, FL 33040
For Sale
$1,489,000
1200-1206 White Street, Key West, FL 33040
For Sale
$1,474,000
1505 Johnson Street, Key West, FL 33040
For Sale
$1,395,000
34 Key Haven Road, Key Haven, FL 33040
For Sale
$1,225,000
1503 Atlantic Boulevard, Key West, FL 33040
Active Under Contract
$1,100,000
1317 Newton Street, Key West, FL 33040
For Sale
$1,095,000
211 Shore Avenue, Big Coppitt, FL 33040
For Sale
$1,095,000
2309 Flagler Avenue, Key West, FL 33040
Active Under Contract
$899,000
209 Shore Avenue, Big Coppitt, FL 33040
Active Under Contract
$875,000
224 Golf Club Drive, Key West, FL 33040
For Sale
$825,000
3705 Eagle Avenue, Key West, FL 33040
For Sale
$825,000
3711 Eagle Avenue, Key West, FL 33040
For Sale
$799,900
1014 Truman Avenue 202, Key West, FL 33040
Active Under Contract
$799,000
3922 Gordon Road, Big Pine Key, FL 33043
For Sale
$780,000
25 Kingfisher Lane, Key West, FL 33040
$725,000
17220 Angelfish Lane, Sugarloaf Key, FL 33042
$725,000
17230 Angelfish Lane, Sugarloaf Key, FL 33042
For Sale
$725,000
308 Margaret Street 3, Key West, FL 33040
For Sale
$699,000
1203 Newton Street 1, Key West, FL 33040
For Sale
$699,000
17220 Angelfish Lane, Sugarloaf Key, FL 33042
For Sale
$649,000
30 Kingfisher Lane, Key West, FL 33040
For Sale
$599,000
816 South Street 4, Key West, FL 33040
For Sale
$569,000
1200 White Street, Key West, FL 33040
For Sale
$479,000
1202 White Street, Key West, FL 33040
For Sale
$330,000
3312 Northside Drive 205, Key West, FL 33040
$69,000
617, Front ST C41 Week 50, Key West, FL 33040
$69,000
617 Front Street 54, Week 36, Key West, FL 33040
$62,000
617 Front St A-52 Week 52, Key West, FL 33040
For Sale
$62,000
617 Front Street A52 Penthouse WK 52, Key West, FL 33040
$59,900
617 Front St A-52 Week 32, Key West, FL 33040
Read what our clients have to say about working with us.
We’d be remiss if we did not end this day with a huge thank you to the folks who got us across the finish line. The best team one could hope for. And lovely people, too! Our deepest gratitude.
We’d be remiss if we did not end this day with a huge thank you to the folks who got us across the finish line. The best team one could hope for. And lovely people, too! Our deepest gratitude.
What a great transaction! Team Kaufelt is the best!
What a great transaction! Team Kaufelt is the best!
Thank you! Thank you so much. We are thoroughly enjoying our new home and Key West!
Thank you! Thank you so much. We are thoroughly enjoying our new home and Key West!
We purchased our new home in Key West in January. Team Kaufelt was our broker for the purchase and was amazing! They not only facilitated the purchase from afar but also handled getting all of the appropriate accounts transferred and in our name as well. Ted Stewart even met the Comcast technician to get that up and running. Without Ted, we would have had to fly back and forth just to get all of this done. Their local knowledge is invaluable and they connected us with a landscaper, cleaning company, insurance broker, etc. They thought of everything!
We purchased our new home in Key West in January. Team Kaufelt was our broker for the purchase and was amazing! They not only facilitated the purchase from afar but also handled getting all of the appropriate accounts transferred and in our name as well. Ted Stewart even met the Comcast technician to get that up and running. Without Ted, we would have had to fly back and forth just to get all of this done. Their local knowledge is invaluable and they connected us with a landscaper, cleaning company, insurance broker, etc. They thought of everything!
Ted was professional, very responsive, and was always a step ahead. Old Town Fitness was the first business we bought in the state of Florida and we are very happy with the customer service we received from Ted Stewart. From minor things like rides to the airport to specific details pertaining to closing the deal, everything was smooth. Thank you for a great transaction. Looking forward to doing our next commercial and/or residential deal with you in the future!
Ted was professional, very responsive, and was always a step ahead. Old Town Fitness was the first business we bought in the state of Florida and we are very happy with the customer service we received from Ted Stewart. From minor things like rides to the airport to specific details pertaining to closing the deal, everything was smooth. Thank you for a great transaction. Looking forward to doing our next commercial and/or residential deal with you in the future!
First-rate marketing, strategizing, and promotion. Hands-on attention to detail from start to finish. They sold our house in two days and curated the entire process with clarity and timeliness. The entire team is polished and presents themselves impeccably. Their response time is extraordinary and respectful of their clients’ needs. This is professionalism at its peak.
First-rate marketing, strategizing, and promotion. Hands-on attention to detail from start to finish. They sold our house in two days and curated the entire process with clarity and timeliness. The entire team is polished and presents themselves impeccably. Their response time is extraordinary and respectful of their clients’ needs. This is professionalism at its peak.
Team Kaufelt was the perfect realtor partner at every step - from taking the most fabulous photos and videos for marketing to prepping our property for showing, vetting the prospective buyers, and keeping us informed at every stage right up to the successful selling of our home. We could not recommend them highly enough! every member of the team was a joy to work with - professional, personable, and knowledgable, what could have been a stressful event to go through was stress-free, thanks to Team Kaufelt!
Team Kaufelt was the perfect realtor partner at every step - from taking the most fabulous photos and videos for marketing to prepping our property for showing, vetting the prospective buyers, and keeping us informed at every stage right up to the successful selling of our home. We could not recommend them highly enough! every member of the team was a joy to work with - professional, personable, and knowledgable, what could have been a stressful event to go through was stress-free, thanks to Team Kaufelt!
A huge thank you to Jackson Kaufelt for his outstanding dedication to selling our home in Key West. When you're selling a piece of your heart, you want a professional who can get you top dollar and guide you smoothly through the entire process. Jackson was available anytime to answer all of our questions (we had a lot of those!), and we trusted his advice as the Kaufelt name is highly respected in Key West Realty. Don't pass up the opportunity to work with a top-notch team. You'll get the absolute best of everything. Thank you!
A huge thank you to Jackson Kaufelt for his outstanding dedication to selling our home in Key West. When you're selling a piece of your heart, you want a professional who can get you top dollar and guide you smoothly through the entire process. Jackson was available anytime to answer all of our questions (we had a lot of those!), and we trusted his advice as the Kaufelt name is highly respected in Key West Realty. Don't pass up the opportunity to work with a top-notch team. You'll get the absolute best of everything. Thank you!
From listing date to sales date, far and away the finest real estate team that we have ever worked with. Thanks to Lyn and Jackson for making the sale of our home totally painless. We have done 3 deals with the Kaufelt team with each one closing on time without a problem.
From listing date to sales date, far and away the finest real estate team that we have ever worked with. Thanks to Lyn and Jackson for making the sale of our home totally painless. We have done 3 deals with the Kaufelt team with each one closing on time without a problem.
My entire experience with Truman & Co. is based solely with Elizabeth Chamberlain. My husband and I have had the good fortune of working with Elizabeth with 4 separate transactions over the past 5+ years in various parts of Old Town and Casa Marina. We have been extremely satisfied with her services and our results in each instance, and would definitely recommend her to anyone interested in buying or selling property in any part of the lower Keys. We live out of state, and our Key West home(s) have been for part-time living. Elizabeth listened to our "wants" for each change we made with homes. She acquired stunning photos and gave great tips on staging. And to the ins and outs of all of the paperwork and deadlines? Well, she handled it all with knowledge and professionalism. She completely walked us through the entire "Key West" purchasing process; putting us at ease. Elizabeth was timely to answer any questions we had and was always available to help us. We were impressed with how quickly she marketed our homes. I recommend to anyone that is in the preliminary steps of searching for a home and/or selling a home to reach out to Elizabeth. In addition, we have referred close friends to use Elizabeth as their realtor which they did both with the purchase and sale of their home. The process went very satisfactorily for my friend, who lives out of the area. I highly recommend Elizabeth from Truman & Co. and will plan to use her again, should the opportunity arise in the future.
My entire experience with Truman & Co. is based solely with Elizabeth Chamberlain. My husband and I have had the good fortune of working with Elizabeth with 4 separate transactions over the past 5+ years in various parts of Old Town and Casa Marina. We have been extremely satisfied with her services and our results in each instance, and would definitely recommend her to anyone interested in buying or selling property in any part of the lower Keys. We live out of state, and our Key West home(s) have been for part-time living. Elizabeth listened to our "wants" for each change we made with homes. She acquired stunning photos and gave great tips on staging. And to the ins and outs of all of the paperwork and deadlines? Well, she handled it all with knowledge and professionalism. She completely walked us through the entire "Key West" purchasing process; putting us at ease. Elizabeth was timely to answer any questions we had and was always available to help us. We were impressed with how quickly she marketed our homes. I recommend to anyone that is in the preliminary steps of searching for a home and/or selling a home to reach out to Elizabeth. In addition, we have referred close friends to use Elizabeth as their realtor which they did both with the purchase and sale of their home. The process went very satisfactorily for my friend, who lives out of the area. I highly recommend Elizabeth from Truman & Co. and will plan to use her again, should the opportunity arise in the future.
Between them, there is so much knowledge and experience.
Between them, there is so much knowledge and experience.
I can not believe how fast my home sold. Also for more than the asking price!
I can not believe how fast my home sold. Also for more than the asking price!
Ted was magnificent! He went way above the norm in helping us find our dream house in the Key West. I would strongly recommend Ted if you are looking to purchase a property in the Keys. Ted listens to what you want and protects your interests. And he doesn’t stop once a contract is signed. He helped us find providers for insurance, furniture, contractors, and also with utilities. Ted did our walk through by FaceTime. He made the whole process very easy. Ted is the man to see if buying in the Keys!!! 5 STAR SERVICE!!!
Ted was magnificent! He went way above the norm in helping us find our dream house in the Key West. I would strongly recommend Ted if you are looking to purchase a property in the Keys. Ted listens to what you want and protects your interests. And he doesn’t stop once a contract is signed. He helped us find providers for insurance, furniture, contractors, and also with utilities. Ted did our walk through by FaceTime. He made the whole process very easy. Ted is the man to see if buying in the Keys!!! 5 STAR SERVICE!!!
Best experience ever! Not only did my agent Ted take me to see every possible home on the market he did it always with a smile and so very positive. I searched for my forever home for seven months and was so frustrated and constantly wanting to give up. Ted would have me regroup and encouraged me to keep looking knowing we would find my perfect home and we did. This was the easy part. The next phase of actually buying and having everything fall into place was only accomplished because Ted was on the job. There are so many moving parts such as the inspection, the loan approval, making sure that everything is done and in a timely manner was his specialty among others. Even after the closing he still continues to help me with the home by helping get the power transferred the water on sending me names for things o need to have taken care of. I had the best buying experience ever and couldn’t be happier about it.
Best experience ever! Not only did my agent Ted take me to see every possible home on the market he did it always with a smile and so very positive. I searched for my forever home for seven months and was so frustrated and constantly wanting to give up. Ted would have me regroup and encouraged me to keep looking knowing we would find my perfect home and we did. This was the easy part. The next phase of actually buying and having everything fall into place was only accomplished because Ted was on the job. There are so many moving parts such as the inspection, the loan approval, making sure that everything is done and in a timely manner was his specialty among others. Even after the closing he still continues to help me with the home by helping get the power transferred the water on sending me names for things o need to have taken care of. I had the best buying experience ever and couldn’t be happier about it.
I met Ted at the dog park in Key West, where our pups hit it off—and the rest is history! One evening, Ted came to my restaurant for dinner. I jokingly asked him for help with a property, and he immediately jumped in, guiding me through the entire process. Over the next two months, we worked closely together. Was it stressful? Absolutely. But with Ted's guidance, it turned into an amazing experience. Buying a home can be challenging, from finding the perfect house to making an offer and organizing everything. But with Ted Stewart by your side, you’re never alone. He’s available any day, at any time, and his knowledge is unmatched. Whether it’s your first home or your tenth, he’ll be there for you. If he doesn’t have an answer, he’ll find it. My wife and I couldn't have asked for a better guide through this process, especially in the Florida Keys. If you're looking to buy here, you know how challenging it can be. My advice? Get Ted on your team, and great things will happen. From day one to closing, the process was smooth and issue-free. But a special shout-out to Ted—he deserves a gold medal. Just give him a call; you won’t regret it!
I met Ted at the dog park in Key West, where our pups hit it off—and the rest is history! One evening, Ted came to my restaurant for dinner. I jokingly asked him for help with a property, and he immediately jumped in, guiding me through the entire process. Over the next two months, we worked closely together. Was it stressful? Absolutely. But with Ted's guidance, it turned into an amazing experience. Buying a home can be challenging, from finding the perfect house to making an offer and organizing everything. But with Ted Stewart by your side, you’re never alone. He’s available any day, at any time, and his knowledge is unmatched. Whether it’s your first home or your tenth, he’ll be there for you. If he doesn’t have an answer, he’ll find it. My wife and I couldn't have asked for a better guide through this process, especially in the Florida Keys. If you're looking to buy here, you know how challenging it can be. My advice? Get Ted on your team, and great things will happen. From day one to closing, the process was smooth and issue-free. But a special shout-out to Ted—he deserves a gold medal. Just give him a call; you won’t regret it!
Ted did an outstanding job assisting us with the purchase of our Key West home. If it wasn't for Ted's patience and expertise of the Key West area, our needs with regard to the type of home, as well as the market, we definitely would not be owning a home there today. From start to finish Ted listened to our needs and wants and was able to find us our perfect home. He took the time to show us different areas, price points as well as pros and cons of living in each area we looked at. Ted was always available via phone, returning calls promptly. He consistently went above and beyond every time we came into town and made sure he had several showings available. Ted has gone above and beyond, not only from purchasing and closing on the house, but finding the right people to maintain our property. We highly recommend Ted to anyone interested in purchasing a property in the Florida Keys, you will definitely not be disappointed.
Ted did an outstanding job assisting us with the purchase of our Key West home. If it wasn't for Ted's patience and expertise of the Key West area, our needs with regard to the type of home, as well as the market, we definitely would not be owning a home there today. From start to finish Ted listened to our needs and wants and was able to find us our perfect home. He took the time to show us different areas, price points as well as pros and cons of living in each area we looked at. Ted was always available via phone, returning calls promptly. He consistently went above and beyond every time we came into town and made sure he had several showings available. Ted has gone above and beyond, not only from purchasing and closing on the house, but finding the right people to maintain our property. We highly recommend Ted to anyone interested in purchasing a property in the Florida Keys, you will definitely not be disappointed.
We used Ted for the sale of our condo and couldn't have picked a better agent to help us and get the job done! We were out of state for the entire process so we were unsure how to make it all happen. Ted knew EXACTLY what to do with all the different moving parts and made the process seamless! His communication skills are excellent. He was available for questions as well as keeping us informed every step of the way. Whenever any kind of issue came up, Ted always found a solution. He is knowledgable of the entire process and has many resources in the community. We couldn't be happier with how easy this sale went and we owe it ALL to Ted and his hard work! Much appreciated! We will definitely use Ted for our next Key West transaction!
We used Ted for the sale of our condo and couldn't have picked a better agent to help us and get the job done! We were out of state for the entire process so we were unsure how to make it all happen. Ted knew EXACTLY what to do with all the different moving parts and made the process seamless! His communication skills are excellent. He was available for questions as well as keeping us informed every step of the way. Whenever any kind of issue came up, Ted always found a solution. He is knowledgable of the entire process and has many resources in the community. We couldn't be happier with how easy this sale went and we owe it ALL to Ted and his hard work! Much appreciated! We will definitely use Ted for our next Key West transaction!
I’ve had a top notch experience with Ted as my agent. He works hard and does it with enthusiasm. He is fantastic with communication and constantly kept me in touch with how the progress of our transaction was progressing. He helped me with negotiating with saved me thousands of dollars. He also connected me with support and service people for before settlement like home inspectors, insurance agents etc who were all very good and has connected me with people to help service my property after settlement such as pool service, landscaping, etc. As a remote buyer, he even stopped by my house to move deliveries inside. I can’t say enough about Ted and highly recommend his services!
I’ve had a top notch experience with Ted as my agent. He works hard and does it with enthusiasm. He is fantastic with communication and constantly kept me in touch with how the progress of our transaction was progressing. He helped me with negotiating with saved me thousands of dollars. He also connected me with support and service people for before settlement like home inspectors, insurance agents etc who were all very good and has connected me with people to help service my property after settlement such as pool service, landscaping, etc. As a remote buyer, he even stopped by my house to move deliveries inside. I can’t say enough about Ted and highly recommend his services!
Ted is the only realtor I would recommend after this experience. He has the knowledge, the passion for the industry and the drive to get even the most complex transactions over the finish line. He turned around every obstacle imaginable within 24 hrs. As soon as one was done he went on to the next. I dont think I could have completed my purchase without his infinite grit and problem solving skills. His professionalism, positivity and deep knowledge of real estate makes him a invaluable asset to anyone buying, selling, managing or renting a property in the Keys and me and my little family will be forever grateful for his hard work. Thank you Ted!
Ted is the only realtor I would recommend after this experience. He has the knowledge, the passion for the industry and the drive to get even the most complex transactions over the finish line. He turned around every obstacle imaginable within 24 hrs. As soon as one was done he went on to the next. I dont think I could have completed my purchase without his infinite grit and problem solving skills. His professionalism, positivity and deep knowledge of real estate makes him a invaluable asset to anyone buying, selling, managing or renting a property in the Keys and me and my little family will be forever grateful for his hard work. Thank you Ted!
Hi Stephanie! Just wanted to thank you for helping us sell out timeshare. Although we hated to sell after 28 years we thought it was time to sell. It'll be tough not seeing our Week 18 friends we made there we can always drive down to visit and stay somewhere in the keys. Best regards, Sandy M
Hi Stephanie! Just wanted to thank you for helping us sell out timeshare. Although we hated to sell after 28 years we thought it was time to sell. It'll be tough not seeing our Week 18 friends we made there we can always drive down to visit and stay somewhere in the keys. Best regards, Sandy M
Thank you, Stephanie - you and your Company did a great job.
Thank you, Stephanie - you and your Company did a great job.
Thank you, Stephanie! You made the process very easy.
Thank you, Stephanie! You made the process very easy.
I would give Jared 10 stars if possible! He is the most professional, knowledgeable, detail oriented, kindest real estate professional we have ever worked with. He worked with us on finding a home and always took time to research the homes before we visited, determining if the criteria we wanted actually matched to the place we were viewing and was always two steps ahead of us in thinking about what needed to be done next in the process. His role in finalizing the purchase process was exemplary. Jared is a role model for any person in real estate!
I would give Jared 10 stars if possible! He is the most professional, knowledgeable, detail oriented, kindest real estate professional we have ever worked with. He worked with us on finding a home and always took time to research the homes before we visited, determining if the criteria we wanted actually matched to the place we were viewing and was always two steps ahead of us in thinking about what needed to be done next in the process. His role in finalizing the purchase process was exemplary. Jared is a role model for any person in real estate!
Jared was so great helping me with my first house he's awesome.
Jared was so great helping me with my first house he's awesome.
I feel very fortunate to have chosen Jared as my buyer’s agent for my Key West house. His knowledge of the Key West market and attention to details is without match. His response to my personal questions was timely and thorough in all situations. I was more impressed how Jared handled the administrative process along with connecting the banks, insurance companies, inspectors, contractors, and other players in my closing process. To say my deal was quick and painless would be an understatement. I owe this to Jared’s work. I highly recommend him!
I feel very fortunate to have chosen Jared as my buyer’s agent for my Key West house. His knowledge of the Key West market and attention to details is without match. His response to my personal questions was timely and thorough in all situations. I was more impressed how Jared handled the administrative process along with connecting the banks, insurance companies, inspectors, contractors, and other players in my closing process. To say my deal was quick and painless would be an understatement. I owe this to Jared’s work. I highly recommend him!
Find Your Dream Home
Stay up-to-date with exclusive news and market updates in Key West.
1205 Truman Ave Key West FL 33040
1205 Truman Ave Key West FL 33040